CEC Gyanesh Kumar Must Answer for Bypassing His Own Commissioners: Prof. Salim Engineer

September 25, 2026

New Delhi: The Vice President of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind (JIH), Prof. Salim Engineer, has expressed serious concern over the way Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has reportedly taken important decisions without properly involving the other two Election Commissioners. He said the revelations about the functioning of the Election Commission of India (ECI) raise serious questions about the independence, transparency and constitutional functioning of this important institution.

In a statement to the media, the JIH Vice President said, “The Indian Express (IE) investigation has revealed that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi raised written objections at least 14 times in 10 months on serious matters relating to voter registration, deletion and restoration of names, the voter database, Form 6 and the Special Summary Revision. They were reportedly kept out of important decisions. This is deeply worrying. The Supreme Court, in its 1995 judgment in the T.N. Seshan case, made it clear that the Election Commission is a multi-member body and that the Chief Election Commissioner is first among equals. The CEC cannot act as if the Election Commission is his personal institution. If the allegations are established, there must be an independent inquiry and appropriate action under the law.”

Prof Salim Engineer said, “The impact of these decisions on ordinary citizens is extremely serious. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has resulted in around 13 crore names being struck off the voters’ list across India. Millions of people have complained that the new process is difficult and requires documents that many citizens do not have. In West Bengal, around 2.7 million voters were removed through SIR. Even more disturbing is the report that appeals were filed for the deletion of 1.61 million voters who had already been cleared for inclusion. The Form 6 issue is equally serious. Form 6 is used by citizens who have attained the age of 18 to enrol as voters. The ECI added a requirement asking applicants to provide the names of parents or grandparents as they appeared in the electoral roll of the last SIR. According to the IE report, both Election Commissioners Vivek Joshi and Sukhbir Singh Sandhu had warned that Form 6 could not be changed in this way without an amendment to the rules. Yet the change was retained by the CEC. If a new requirement affecting the right to vote requires a change in law, the Election Commission cannot simply make that change on its own. Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) are the statutory authorities responsible for additions, deletions and corrections in electoral rolls. Yet the two Commissioners reportedly raised concerns that the ECINet database was being centralised at the ECI without giving these officers proper access to operate it.”

The JIH Vice President also expressed concern over the prolonged delay in the Special Summary Revision (SSR), stating, “The SSR is an important annual exercise to keep electoral rolls updated and to ensure that as many eligible 18-year-olds as possible are included. With four qualifying dates – January 1, April 1, July 1 and October 1, young citizens can become eligible to vote throughout the year. Yet the ECI has not conducted the annual SSR since January 2024. The fact that the CEC Gyanesh Kumar reportedly sought a legal opinion on whether SSR was required while SIR was underway, while Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi strongly advocated its resumption, makes the delay even more concerning. SSR is not merely a formality; it is essential for keeping electoral rolls current, accurate and inclusive.”

Prof. Salim Engineer said, “Democracy must make it easier for eligible citizens to become voters, not harder. The right to vote is meaningful only when eligible citizens can enter the electoral roll without unnecessary barriers. The Election Commission belongs to the Constitution and the people of India, not to any individual office-holder. Depriving citizens of their fundamental right to vote is not merely an administrative lapse; it is a grave betrayal of the country and its people. The officials responsible for this must be subjected to a thorough and impartial inquiry, and strict action must be taken against those found responsible, in accordance with the law. Protecting the voter list means protecting the foundation of Indian democracy.”

Spread the love

0 Comments