New Delhi: Malik Motasim Khan, Vice President of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind (JIH), has expressed deep concern over the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) announcement of a nation-wide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls across 12 States and Union Territories. Drawing lessons from the recently concluded SIR in Bihar, he urged the ECI to ensure transparency, fairness, and inclusivity in the process to prevent another wave of mass voter deletions.
In a statement to the media, Khan said:
“The Bihar SIR was marked by serious irregularities, unrealistic timelines, and an alarming lack of transparency. Nearly 65 lakh names were initially deleted from the draft rolls, an unprecedented number — and even after revisions, 47 lakh voters remained excluded. The exercise placed the burden of proof on citizens instead of the state, effectively turning an administrative revision into a quasi-citizenship verification drive. Before extending this process nationwide, the ECI must respond to key questions that go to the heart of democratic integrity.”
He further outlined several critical questions that the ECI must answer before proceeding. He asked what lessons had been learned from the Bihar experience and what specific changes were made to the SIR guidelines. He also questioned the timeline set by the ECI for the second phase of the SIR, emphasizing that conducting such an extensive exercise within just one month would create numerous problems. He asked why the ECI is not providing sufficient time for this crucial process. He also questioned the continued use of 2002/2003 as the cutoff year when no citizenship verification was carried out then, and whether the identification of “illegal foreigners” remains an objective of the SIR. Further, he sought clarity on why Aadhaar is rejected as proof of citizenship despite clear instructions by Supreme Court while other non-citizenship documents are accepted, and who exactly qualifies for exemption based on inclusion in the 2002/2003 rolls—the individual, their children, or extended family members.
He raised doubts about the revised house-to-house verification process, asking whether it now permits the addition of new voters during the draft stage, and how the ECI plans to ensure acknowledgment receipts for all submitted forms. Khan also pointed to reports of officials or Booth Level Officers (BLOs) filling forms without consent and asked what safeguards have been instituted to prevent such forgery. The treatment of migrant workers, who often face exclusion due to mobility and lack of documentation was highlighted as another serious concern.
On the issue of inclusivity, JIH Vice President noted the fall in women’s representation during the Bihar SIR and asked what corrective measures would prevent a similar outcome. He questioned whether those excluded from the rolls would receive due notice and hearing before deletion, or be forced to reapply as “new voters.” Additionally, he sought clarification on why common identification documents such as PAN cards, driving licenses, MNREGA job cards, ration cards, and bank passbooks— regularly accepted in other ECI processes have been omitted from the approved list.
Finally, Malik Motasim Khan emphasized the need for technological transparency and accuracy, asking whether the ECI has integrated an effective de-duplication system and whether it will release machine-readable draft and final electoral rolls for public scrutiny. He said these steps are essential to uphold voter confidence and prevent manipulation or error.
M M Khan added:
“Electoral roll revisions should not resemble citizenship verification drives. The right to vote must be safeguarded, not obstructed through bureaucratic procedures.”
He urged the Election Commission to publicly clarify these issues and ensure that no citizen is disenfranchised due to documentation hurdles or administrative opacity. “Free and fair elections demand inclusivity and trust. The ECI must act transparently, uphold constitutional principles, and protect every Indian’s right to vote,” he concluded.





0 Comments