No government or court can do away with Personal Law of any religious minority: Jamaat

November 5, 2015

Personal-LawNew Delhi, 01 Nov 2015: Jamaat-e-Islami Hind has expressed its strong apprehensions over court observations about Uniform Civil Code and Muslim Personal Law. Maulana Syed Jalaluddin Umari, Ameer (National President) of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind has said that Muslims and other minorities follow their Personal Law because the Constitution of India has guaranteed their right to do so, and no government or court, therefore, can do away with Muslim Personal Law. He also said that a Common Civil Code is practically impossible for a multi-religious country like India.

“Common Civil Code is just a recommendation, and does not carry any constitutional status. It is on government to formulate it or not. The Constitution has given right to the minorities to follow their Personal Laws. The government, Supreme Court or any court cannot take any step to end the personal law of Muslims or any other minorities. The Constitution has given a guarantee to them to follow their personal laws,” said Maulana Umari who has authored several books on Islam.

Commenting on the Muslim Personal Law often being dragged into court debates, Maulana Umari said:

“If a court has any objection to any article of the Personal Law, it can and should consult and discuss with the experts of that personal law. But it is not right if one says that Personal Law should be done away with and Common Civil Code should replace it.”

“The government has often made it clear that if any decision is taken on Common Civil Code it should be based on consensus. And it is not easy to get such consensus. It is almost impossible to formulate a common civil code which is acceptable to Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Jains and also tribals. That is why the government does not move forward. Despite the fact, some are talking about Common Civil Code again and again. It is included in the Fundamental Rights that all minorities can follow their personal law. The government and court rather should see if personal law is being followed or not. If they face any problem regarding any article or issue related to Personal Law, its experts should be consulted with to get the viewpoint of Islam. What the experts say should be acted upon.”

He said Common Civil Code is not possible in a multi-religion country like India.

“It is not possible and that is why the government does not take any step. To formulate a law that is acceptable to all – and people accept it even if it is against their religion – is not possible. Our Constitution has given rights to tribals also to resolve their issues according to their customs and traditions. In that context, you cannot expect a consensus Common Civil Code. But those advocating for Common Civil Code may want to impose something with majoritarian force, that will be completely illegal and unconstitutional,” said Maulana Umari.

On why courts continue referring to Uniform Civil Code, Maulana Umari said:

“As the word Common Civil Code has been included in the Preamble, the court thinks that the government should take steps forward but it ignores the compulsion of the government that formulation of such law is not easy and if you make something with force it will not be acceptable to all. And what about the Constitutional guarantee given to all communities to follow their personal law? Since the British era till date, Muslims have been practicing their personal law. The British law was carried as it is by our government after independence.”

On the prevalence of evils in the Muslim society that make Islam a target of criticism, Maulana Umari said:

“Evils are in all societies. But the problem is that one case of a Muslim is seen as the case of all Muslims. One or two cases from the twenty-crore Muslim population are presented in a way as if the entire community is doing the same act. This is wrong. It is an attempt to tarnish the image of Muslims.”

Spread the love

0 Comments